Facebook* users debated the fairness of Avanesyan's sentence.
Karen Avanesyan, who remained in Khankendi, was convicted on a fabricated terrorist charge, Armenian social media users suggested, while Azerbaijani users considered the verdict fair. Details of the case are known only from Azerbaijani sources, noted lawyer Ara Ghazaryan.
As reported by the "Caucasian Knot," on December 25, the Ganja court sentenced Karen Avanesyan, who remained in Khankendi (the Armenian name is Stepanakert) after the exodus of Karabakhis to Armenia, to 16 years in prison. The man was found guilty of a terrorist attack, an attempted murder of two or more people, and the illegal possession of weapons and ammunition.
According to the court, Avanesyan, having planned the terrorist attacks, acquired and stored a Kalashnikov assault rifle and a large number of hand grenades. On September 14, he took the ammunition he had hidden earlier and entered an empty house, where he opened fire indiscriminately at police officers and threw several grenades at them. Three police officers were wounded. Avanesyan, 58, had never had any problems with the law and was registered as mentally ill, his acquaintances noted, and considered the case fabricated.
As of 12:50 p.m. Moscow time on December 29, Facebook* users had left more than 1,030 comments under the "Caucasian Knot" post about Avanesyan's sentencing.
Some users with Armenian names questioned the Azerbaijani security forces' version of events. "Do you really believe this man could handle a machine gun professionally? You're disgracing yourselves," wrote Hovik Badalyan. "The case is fabricated. They've turned a sick man into a 'Terrorist Rambo,'" said Nina Davidyan.
"They're trying a sick man who was simply framed to fabricate a dirty case," opined Marine Manukyan. "It would be funny if it weren't so sad. Do they really believe this story?" – Elya Bagishyan asked.
Other Armenian social media users didn't rule out Avanesyan's crime, but doubted the terrorist motive behind his actions.
"We don't know the real reasons for his actions. We're being shown a ready-made picture. He doesn't look like a terrorist or a partisan. We need to listen to the person, not make things up," Zhanna Avanesova noted.
"He's mentally ill and didn't serve in the army for that very reason. If he had, he could have caused real damage," Ella Ange expressed her opinion. "Defending one's homeland from occupation cannot be considered terrorism," stated Angela Achikgiozian.
After the exodus of the Armenian population from Nagorno-Karabakh, no more than 40 residents remained, including ethnic Armenians, former State Minister Artak Beglaryan stated on October 14, 2023. Earlier, on October 2, 2023, the UN mission stated that between 50 and 1,000 ethnic Armenians remained in Karabakh. The original UN statement, which cited these figures, was published on the "Caucasian Knot." By early September 2024, only 14 Armenians remained in the region. One of the last Armenian residents of Karabakh, 70-year-old Vera Aghasyan, died at the end of October 2024.
In turn, users with Azerbaijani names in their nicknames considered Avanesyan's sentence fair. "He stayed not to live, but to kill. Azerbaijan does not organize terrorist attacks in your country, but he shot and threw grenades. He was convicted according to the law," said Almaz Shakarova, in particular.
"A man came with a machine gun and grenades and wounded police officers. Were we supposed to reward him? Anyone who raises arms against us will be punished," wrote Oktay Aliyev.
"In response to the respect shown to him, he committed treason. He bit the hand that fed him," expressed the opinion of Elgün Hemidli. "He is an Azerbaijani citizen and was convicted under Azerbaijani law. Nationality has nothing to do with it," noted Cavid Iskenderli.
"He doesn't seem sick. Everything was planned: he hid the weapon and waited. The verdict is fair," wrote Rəşad Qənimətli. "He hid an assault rifle and grenades in advance and went to kill people. There is video footage. Before writing, we need to study the facts," said Azat Abbas.
A video report about the incident with Avanesyan was published on September 15, 2025, on the YouTube channel "Orxan Sirinli ŞO TV". The video, edited from footage from street surveillance cameras, shows a man walking along deserted streets. He enters one of the houses, then comes out holding a bag or backpack, and then continues walking. The man's weapon is not visible, and there is no video footage of the shooting in the video. Some of the footage is superimposed with retouched photos from the scene of the shootout and a portrait of Avanesyan.
Karen Avanesyan's sentence was handed down "in the absence of any reliable information about the observance of his right to a fair trial and other fundamental rights during the trial," stated lawyer Ara Ghazaryan.
"Furthermore, information about this trial is available exclusively from limited sources in the Azerbaijani press. There is no reliable and verifiable information about the legal basis for the trial, the factual circumstances of the case, or whether Karen Avanesyan's procedural rights were observed or whether his right to a fair trial was guaranteed," Panorama.am quoted the lawyer as saying on December 27.
Translated automatically via Google translate from https://www.kavkaz-uzel.eu/articles/419502